Home > Personal Finance > The Retirement Question Everyone Has to Answer: Roth or Traditional 401K?

Comments 0 Comments

Many companies who provide 401K retirement plans are now starting to offer a Roth 401K option. How do you know which one to choose? Both savings vehicles allow you to make voluntary salary deferrals of the lesser of 100% of your pay or $18,000 (the limit in 2016) per year. And if you are 50 or older, you can typically contribute an additional $6,000. While the limits are the same, the deferrals and retirement distributions are taxed differently in the two plans.

A traditional 401K allows for pre-tax deferrals, meaning that they are deducted from the taxable income that is reported on your W-2 at the end of the year, reducing your taxable income and the income tax due in that year. As the investments grow, no tax is due on any gain until you withdraw money from the plan. At that time, you will pay ordinary income tax on all withdrawals (plus a 10% federal penalty if you are not at least 59½, or in the event of a few other less-common situations). You make pre-tax deferrals but receive taxable distributions.

A Roth 401K, named for the late Senator William Roth, requires that deferrals be made with after tax–dollars. This means that you will not save any income taxes at the time of the contribution. Similar to the traditional 401K option, the investments grow free of taxation. However, while traditional 401K withdrawals are taxable, all qualified distributions from a Roth 401K are income tax-free. Qualified distributions are those in which the account is at least five years old and the distribution is made due to disability, death or upon reaching age 59½. So your contributions are taxable but your distributions are generally income tax-free.

Which Option Is Better?

The answer is actually quite simple. If you are in a higher tax bracket when making contributions than the tax bracket you are in while taking distributions, you should choose the traditional version. If, however, you are in a lower tax bracket when making contributions than the one while taking distributions, you should choose the Roth version. If the tax rates are identical pre- and post-retirement, then it makes absolutely no difference.

When comparing the two options, it is necessary to adjust the contributions for taxation. Since the Roth contributions are after tax, for comparison purposes, the deferral must be reduced by the income taxes paid before the contribution is made. So an $18,000 contribution to a traditional 401K plan would be compared to a $15,300 contribution to a Roth 401K plan if the taxpayer is in the 15% tax bracket (15% X $18,000 = $2,700, and $18,000 – $2,700 = $15,300). Essentially, both contributions required $18,000 of gross pay. Upon retirement, the traditional 401K balance must be reduced by taxes due on distribution, while the Roth 401K balance is paid tax-free.

The chart below compares an $18,000/year-contribution for a traditional 401K to an after-tax contribution of $15,300/year to a Roth 401K, assuming a 15% pre-retirement income tax rate. It illustrates the after-tax retirement balances using 10%, 15% and 20% post-retirement tax rates. The investments are assumed to earn a hypothetical rate of return of 7% per year.

chart copy

These examples are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only. The rates of return do not represent any actual investment and cannot be guaranteed. Any investment involves potential loss of principle.

Notice that when the pre-retirement tax rate of 15% is higher than the post-retirement rate of 10%, the traditional 401K plan has the advantage. When the pre-retirement rate of 15% is lower than the post-retirement tax rate of 20%, the Roth 401K is a better choice. However, when the pre- and post-retirement tax rates are equal at 15%, the net for the Roth and the Traditional 401K plans are identical.

So if you expect your income tax rate to decrease in retirement, choose the traditional 401K. If you expect taxes to increase during retirement, choose the Roth 401K. If you are not comfortable guessing what your tax rates will be at that time, then split your contributions evenly between the two options.

Remember, no matter what you’ve planned for retirement, it pays to know where your credit score stands and how everyday habits are affecting your credit. You can check your scores, updated every 14 days, for free on Credit.com.

More Money-Saving Reads:

Image: iStock

Comments on articles and responses to those comments are not provided or commissioned by a bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by a bank advertiser. It is not a bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Please note that our comments are moderated, so it may take a little time before you see them on the page. Thanks for your patience.

Credit.com receives compensation for the financial products and services advertised on this site if our users apply for and sign up for any of them.

Hello, Reader!

Thanks for checking out Credit.com. We hope you find the site and the journalism we produce useful. We wanted to take some time to tell you a bit about ourselves.

Our People

The Credit.com editorial team is staffed by a team of editors and reporters, each with many years of financial reporting experience. We’ve worked for places like the New York Times, American Banker, Frontline, TheStreet.com, Business Insider, ABC News, NBC News, CNBC and many others. We also employ a few freelancers and more than 50 contributors (these are typically subject matter experts from the worlds of finance, academia, politics, business and elsewhere).

Our Reporting

We take great pains to ensure that the articles, video and graphics you see on Credit.com are thoroughly reported and fact-checked. Each story is read by two separate editors, and we adhere to the highest editorial standards. We’re not perfect, however, and if you see something that you think is wrong, please email us at editorial team [at] credit [dot] com,

The Credit.com editorial team is committed to providing our readers and viewers with sound, well-reported and understandable information designed to inform and empower. We won’t tell you what to do. We will, however, do our best to explain the consequences of various actions, thereby arming you with the information you need to make decisions that are in your best interests. We also write about things relating to money and finance we think are interesting and want to share.

In addition to appearing on Credit.com, our articles are syndicated to dozens of other news sites. We have more than 100 partners, including MSN, ABC News, CBS News, Yahoo, Marketwatch, Scripps, Money Magazine and many others. This network operates similarly to the Associated Press or Reuters, except we focus almost exclusively on issues relating to personal finance. These are not advertorial or paid placements, rather we provide these articles to our partners in most cases for free. These relationships create more awareness of Credit.com in general and they result in more traffic to us as well.

Our Business Model

Credit.com’s journalism is largely supported by an e-commerce business model. Rather than rely on revenue from display ad impressions, Credit.com maintains a financial marketplace separate from its editorial pages. When someone navigates to those pages, and applies for a credit card, for example, Credit.com will get paid what is essentially a finder’s fee if that person ends up getting the card. That doesn’t mean, however, that our editorial decisions are informed by the products available in our marketplace. The editorial team chooses what to write about and how to write about it independently of the decisions and priorities of the business side of the company. In fact, we maintain a strict and important firewall between the editorial and business departments. Our mission as journalists is to serve the reader, not the advertiser. In that sense, we are no different from any other news organization that is supported by ad revenue.

Visitors to Credit.com are also able to register for a free Credit.com account, which gives them access to a tool called The Credit Report Card. This tool provides users with two free credit scores and a breakdown of the information in their Experian credit report, updated twice monthly. Again, this tool is entirely free, and we mention that frequently in our articles, because we think that it’s a good thing for users to have access to data like this. Separate from its educational value, there is also a business angle to the Credit Report Card. Registered users can be matched with products and services for which they are most likely to qualify. In other words, if you register and you find that your credit is less than stellar, Credit.com won’t recommend a high-end platinum credit card that requires an excellent credit score You’d likely get rejected, and that’s no good for you or Credit.com. You’d be no closer to getting a product you need, there’d be a wasted inquiry on your credit report, and Credit.com wouldn’t get paid. These are essentially what are commonly referred to as "targeted ads" in the world of the Internet. Despite all of this, however, even if you never apply for any product, the Credit Report Card will remain free, and none of this will impact how the editorial team reports on credit and credit scores.

Your Stories

Lastly, much of what we do is informed by our own experiences as well as the experiences of our readers. We want to tell your stories if you’re interested in sharing them. Please email us at story ideas [at] credit [dot] com with ideas or visit us on Facebook or Twitter.

Thanks for stopping by.

- The Credit.com Editorial Team