Home > Managing Debt > When Health Insurance Doesn’t Save You Much Money

Comments 0 Comments

Q: How much does gallbladder surgery cost?
A: Anywhere from $5,865 to $94,897.

Here’s another one: How can a person with good insurance wind up paying $6,104.64 for gallbladder surgery? Well, it’s not hard.

We set out on this quest after hearing from Justin Evans, of Bonney Lake, Wash., who has pretty good employer-sponsored insurance, and who after his gallbladder surgery got bills for around $50,000. He is being asked to pay $6,104.64 as his responsibility, though he was in-network and his insurance has a $2,000 deductible.

Evans’ email said:

“On Jan. 11th, I underwent an emergency Gall Bladder removal surgery. It went extremely well and from the time I walked into the ER until the time I walked out after surgery was a total of 13 hours. I’m just now starting to get bills and it is ridiculous! The Hospital stay alone was over $44,000, for 13 hours! Insurance and adjustments left me with over $3,600 out of pocket for the hospital. That’s not to mention the ultrasound charges, xray charges, surgeon charges & anesthesiologist and any other bills I’ve yet to see. So far it’s nearly $50k in charges. I can’t understand how 13 hours in the hospital can cost more than my monthly mortgage for 4 years or the same price as a fully loaded BMW X5! … I’m just not sure why such a routine surgery performed between 500,000 – 700,000 times a year can cost so much.”

Evans, 35, is an operations manager for a machine and fabrication shop. His Premera Blue Cross insurance is through work, and all of his doctors, hospitals and others were in-network – as far as he knew, until he received a bill from an out-of-network emergency room doc service.

Evans made a spreadsheet of the prices and reimbursement rates, shown below.

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

First, Some Comparisons

At clearhealthcosts.com, we’re about to roll out a big dataset with cash or self-pay prices for bigger-ticket items, so we’ve learned a lot about what cash patients pay for things like gallbladder surgery.

At the Surgery Center of Oklahoma, in Oklahoma City, the price is $5,865, all-inclusive. So Evans could have gotten his entire operation for less than his co-pay, and also a round-trip airline ticket from Seattle to Oklahoma City, which is around $300, would have brought him in around $6,165 – just a smidge more than what he is being asked to pay – on top of the insurance company’s stated outlay of $15,754.15.

The self-pay price for a gallbladder removal at Rochester General in Rochester, N.Y., is $6,260.91, without anesthesia and doctor’s bill.

At the Banner Baywood Medical Center in Mesa, Ariz., the price for a laparoscopic gallbladder removal is $94,897 as a list price, but the self-pay discounted price is from $11,611 to $14,223.

One friend who lives in the New York metro area told us about her gallbladder surgery that had a total bill of $13,975.21 — and the insurance company paid $7,752.57 and she paid $1,111.52.

Finally, just below is a screenshot from his insurance company’s website explaining how much they estimated such a procedure would cost. They estimated $17,936 for his surgery at Good Samaritan Hospital in Puyallup, Wash., and he was billed $44,487.10. (I asked the hospital what their self-pay rate was, and they told me that their self-pay rate is the same as the chargemaster rate. However, they said they also offer uninsured patients “prompt pay discounts up to 40% by paying their entire bill within 30 days of the first statement.”)

Insurance Company Estimate

Click to enlarge

What Cost Him So Much?

The hospital charged $44,487.10 – don’t forget the 10 cents! – of which his insurance company, Premera, paid $15,404.51. Evans paid $100 for this, and he’s being asked for another $3,617. That’s his 20%.

For the in-network surgeon, the $1,250 price means that Evans is billed for $946.91. (His deductible is $2,000.) And, he gets to pay another $260.45 for the surgeon’s in-patient treatment, although the doctor is in-network. Part of the in-network anesthesiologist also fell on his deductible, for $572.02.

Mount Rainier ER Physicians asks for $646, none of it covered by insurance. (They are not in his network, though the hospital is). He said he didn’t know they were out-of-network. We hear this a lot: in-network hospital, emergency situation, out-of-network docs or anesthesiologists (as if you are expected to ask, while lying on a gurney writhing in pain, “I know this is an in-network hospital, but I just want to make sure: do you take my insurance?”).

The X-ray, ultrasound and pathology bills are entirely covered by insurance.

A Closer Look at the Charges

With the in-network charges, Evans’s plan has an in-network individual deductible of $2,000, and an individual in-network out-of-pocket maximum of $6,000. His insurance leaves him responsible for 20% of the emergency-room costs, and 20% of an in-network emergency-room facility (with a $100 copay), inpatient facility and many other items.

So of the hospital bill, for example, he wrote: “Insurance covered $15,404.51, which is 80% of their allotted amount for service, which is $19,121.50. My ER co-pay of $100 brought that down to $19,021.50. My bill for the $3,617 is roughly my 20% portion of the co-insurance, there was about a $200 discrepancy, but it was overpayment on their end. The $25,365.59 that was waived was the balance that insurance wouldn’t cover and was basically known over charging.”

Evans emailed that he had received a call from Bethany Sexton, vice president of revenue cycle for Multicare, the parent of Good Samaritan Hospital, referring to his chats with me.

Evans raised with her his objections to what he regarded as a high bill. “We discussed the consequences of [my] not paying the balance and ultimately at the end of the 4th billing cycle (120 days) it would be turned over to collections of which it could affect my credit should the delinquency continue beyond 60 days with the collection company. We also discussed payment options and financial aid options [for] which she is sending me information.”

Evans considered having his bill reviewed by a professional for discrepancies, and disputing the bill, however he decided against it because his insurance company told him that even if some charges were thrown out, the insurer would still most likely allow that $19,121.50 and his 20% would remain unchanged. When he complained that it seemed like an overcharge, she told him that if the hospital reduced charges, and instead charged what it really cost, they would be leaving money on the table. There’s no incentive to reduce the charges, essentially.

Now when it comes to the out-of-network charges: Out-of-network providers can bill the insurance company whatever they want. Then after (or if) they get paid, they bill the patient for the balance (it’s called balance billing). You can appeal that with your provider and your insurer, and Evans has. In some states, laws protect consumers either by prohibiting this practice, requiring prominent display of signs showing that out-of-network providers are working at in-network facilities, and so on.

The Kaiser Family Foundation compiled the state laws about that. In Washington, in-network balance billing is not permitted, but out-of-network is.

What Can You Do Under the Circumstances?

First, you’re not alone. A recent Kaiser Family Foundation report found that one in three Americans had trouble with medical debt. Many of those are insured, but have issues like Evans’s.

“Just because you have good insurance that doesn’t mean you won’t have large out-of-pocket costs. Take the time to understand your insurance coverage and confirm that you are working with in-network providers if that will save you money,” says Gerri Detweiler, director of consumer education at Credit.com. “And unless it’s an emergency, shop around! Even with insurance, the cost you may wind up paying can vary tremendously.”

Here are some tips for dealing with medical bills.

  1. Keep all your bills. If you don’t get an itemized bill, ask for it. The bill from the provider and the bill from the insurance company should be compared for anomalies and errors.
  2. Know your insurance plan. Evans was surprised to see that his plan requires him to pay 20% of emergency charges. The plan language can be very confusing. If it’s not clear, ask.
  3. If you think that the bill or the insurance company payout might be wrong, go on record immediately in writing as contesting the bill and the payout. Procedures for this vary but a certified letter will establish a paper trail.
  4. Keep good records of who you spoke with and wrote to and when. Keep the names, phone numbers and other identifying factors: “Ms. Smith, Premera customer service, 216-xxx-xxxx, extension 1435.”
  5. Analyze the bill. Some experts say 20% of hospital bills have some identifiable error; others say the number is much higher, approaching 100%. There are services that will do this for you; they are generally called medical bill advocates. If you’re going this route, make sure you know what you’re paying for. Your HR department may be a good resource here.

So you have to pay?

“If the provider will allow you to make payments, that may be your cheapest option as most won’t charge interest,” Detweiler says. “Review the itemized bill carefully and question any charges you aren’t sure are legitimate. And don’t be afraid to try to negotiate. If you can come up with a lump sum — even if that means charging it — you may be able to knock a substantial portion off the bill.”

Detweiler adds that even if you are making payments, your bill could get sent to collections. “So always make those payments on time and reach out to the provider if you will be late. Monitor your credit reports and scores to make sure medical bills haven’t been sent to collections without your knowledge.”

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a federal agency, has some tools. Your state insurance department, or your state attorney general, or the Better Business Bureau, may also be avenues of appeal.

Here’s another option that worked for one person: Our friends over at WBUR public radio in Boston wrote about a patient who appealed for a year a charge of $1,126 for a 2-inch bandage, to no avail. The patient posted the link for the story on the hospital’s Facebook page. The following day, the patient received an email from the hospital apologizing and granting her a $1,124 credit.

[Editor’s Note: If you’re worried about how medical bills could be affecting your credit, you can monitor your credit scores for free on Credit.com. Also, you can pull free copies of your credit reports once a year.]

More on Managing Debt:

Image: nito100

Comments on articles and responses to those comments are not provided or commissioned by a bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by a bank advertiser. It is not a bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Please note that our comments are moderated, so it may take a little time before you see them on the page. Thanks for your patience.

Credit.com receives compensation for the financial products and services advertised on this site if our users apply for and sign up for any of them.

Hello, Reader!

Thanks for checking out Credit.com. We hope you find the site and the journalism we produce useful. We wanted to take some time to tell you a bit about ourselves.

Our People

The Credit.com editorial team is staffed by a team of editors and reporters, each with many years of financial reporting experience. We’ve worked for places like the New York Times, American Banker, Frontline, TheStreet.com, Business Insider, ABC News, NBC News, CNBC and many others. We also employ a few freelancers and more than 50 contributors (these are typically subject matter experts from the worlds of finance, academia, politics, business and elsewhere).

Our Reporting

We take great pains to ensure that the articles, video and graphics you see on Credit.com are thoroughly reported and fact-checked. Each story is read by two separate editors, and we adhere to the highest editorial standards. We’re not perfect, however, and if you see something that you think is wrong, please email us at editorial team [at] credit [dot] com,

The Credit.com editorial team is committed to providing our readers and viewers with sound, well-reported and understandable information designed to inform and empower. We won’t tell you what to do. We will, however, do our best to explain the consequences of various actions, thereby arming you with the information you need to make decisions that are in your best interests. We also write about things relating to money and finance we think are interesting and want to share.

In addition to appearing on Credit.com, our articles are syndicated to dozens of other news sites. We have more than 100 partners, including MSN, ABC News, CBS News, Yahoo, Marketwatch, Scripps, Money Magazine and many others. This network operates similarly to the Associated Press or Reuters, except we focus almost exclusively on issues relating to personal finance. These are not advertorial or paid placements, rather we provide these articles to our partners in most cases for free. These relationships create more awareness of Credit.com in general and they result in more traffic to us as well.

Our Business Model

Credit.com’s journalism is largely supported by an e-commerce business model. Rather than rely on revenue from display ad impressions, Credit.com maintains a financial marketplace separate from its editorial pages. When someone navigates to those pages, and applies for a credit card, for example, Credit.com will get paid what is essentially a finder’s fee if that person ends up getting the card. That doesn’t mean, however, that our editorial decisions are informed by the products available in our marketplace. The editorial team chooses what to write about and how to write about it independently of the decisions and priorities of the business side of the company. In fact, we maintain a strict and important firewall between the editorial and business departments. Our mission as journalists is to serve the reader, not the advertiser. In that sense, we are no different from any other news organization that is supported by ad revenue.

Visitors to Credit.com are also able to register for a free Credit.com account, which gives them access to a tool called The Credit Report Card. This tool provides users with two free credit scores and a breakdown of the information in their Experian credit report, updated twice monthly. Again, this tool is entirely free, and we mention that frequently in our articles, because we think that it’s a good thing for users to have access to data like this. Separate from its educational value, there is also a business angle to the Credit Report Card. Registered users can be matched with products and services for which they are most likely to qualify. In other words, if you register and you find that your credit is less than stellar, Credit.com won’t recommend a high-end platinum credit card that requires an excellent credit score You’d likely get rejected, and that’s no good for you or Credit.com. You’d be no closer to getting a product you need, there’d be a wasted inquiry on your credit report, and Credit.com wouldn’t get paid. These are essentially what are commonly referred to as "targeted ads" in the world of the Internet. Despite all of this, however, even if you never apply for any product, the Credit Report Card will remain free, and none of this will impact how the editorial team reports on credit and credit scores.

Your Stories

Lastly, much of what we do is informed by our own experiences as well as the experiences of our readers. We want to tell your stories if you’re interested in sharing them. Please email us at story ideas [at] credit [dot] com with ideas or visit us on Facebook or Twitter.

Thanks for stopping by.

- The Credit.com Editorial Team