The Top Rental Markets to Buy an Investment Property

For real estate investors looking for new, profitable markets, Texas offers some untapped opportunities. So does Florida. RealtyTrac and RentRage identified the 25 hidden-gem, single-family rental markets across the country, and they’re all in 15 states no farther west than Texas.

The companies analyzed national housing data of three-bedroom single-family homes to produce the list, which is limited to counties with populations of 100,000 or more. They compared properties by gross rental yield (gross annual rental income divided by property purchase price or market value) and the properties’ expected return on investment. Within the top 25, investor purchases made up 5% or less of residential sales May through July, and unemployment rates were at or below 7.5%. The national unemployment rate is 7.3%.

Rental property can be a great investment, but it can also be a costly one, so finding a market to maximize profit can be crucial to success. This is especially true for individuals or smaller institutional investors, who may be dealing with inventories dominated by big buyers, according to Daren Blomquist, vice president at RealtyTrac.

“With this analysis we’ve identified the top overlooked markets where single family rentals still make good financial sense but where there is little to no competition from the big players,” Blomquist said in a news release about the report.

States with counties on the list include Texas, Oklahoma, New York, Tennessee, Florida, Louisiana, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Missouri, Kansas, Michigan, Maryland, Connecticut, Virginia, Wisconsin and Alabama. Texas and Florida each had three counties on the list, while New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Missouri and Alabama each had two.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, Georgia counties dominate the most investor-saturated markets, as determined by a report analyzing the same data.

Hidden-Gem Rental Markets

We’ve listed the top 10 rental markets out of the 25 identified in the report, including the metropolitan statistical areas within the ranked counties.

1. Wichita County, Texas

Metro Area: Wichita Falls

Median Market Value: $84,000

Median Rent Value: $938

2. Lubbock County, Texas

Metro Area: Lubbock

Median Market Value: $111,000

Median Rent Value: $1,089

3. Canadian County, Oklahoma

Metro Area: Oklahoma City

Median Market Value: $131,000

Median Rent Value: $1,176

4. Williamson County, Texas

Metro Area: Austin-Round Rock

Median Market Value: $ 158,000

Median Rent Value: $1,403

5. Monroe County, New York

Metro Area: Rochester

Median Market Value: $121,000

Median Rent Value: $1,043

6. Davidson County, Tennessee

Metro Area: Nashville-Davidson-Murfreesboro-Franklin

Median Market Value: $149,000

Median Rent Value: $1,263

7. Alachua County, Florida

Metro Area: Gainesville

Median Market Value: $139,000

Median Rent Value: $1,175

8. Schenectady County, New York

Metro Area: Albany-Schenectady-Troy

Median Market Value: $153,000

Median Rent Value: $1,278

9. Jefferson County, Louisiana

Metro Area: New Orleans-Metairie

Median Market Value: $153,000

Median Rent Value: $1,260

10. Allegheny County, Pennsylvania

Metro Area: Pittsburgh

Median Market Value: $126,000

Median Rent Value: $1,034

Image: iStock

You Might Also Like

A father and son smile at each other
Becoming an authorized user is a common tip for individuals tryin... Read More

September 13, 2021


A woman shakes the hand of the man who interviewed her.
Long-term unemployment can really hurt—and not just financially... Read More

August 4, 2021


A stock market graph, similar to the trajectory of GameStop stock, is displayed on a tablet. A blank piece of paper and a pen are next to the tablet, and all sit on a wooden tabletop.
GameStop, a dying video game retailer, has blown past epic propor... Read More

January 28, 2021