How Identity Theft Cost a Woman Her Disability Check

Many people find out their identities have been stolen when they try to file their taxes and discover someone has already used their Social Security number to get a fraudulent tax refund. In what could be considered a best-case scenario, victims of taxpayer identity theft end up dealing with an especially laborious tax-filing process and a delayed refund.

Jennifer Marban’s identity theft story is not the best-case scenario. Marban lost her disability check after someone used her Social Security number to file a fraudulent tax return, reports WATE 6 in Knoxville, Tenn. Marban is totally disabled and receives $1,080 a month in Social Security benefits, which she uses to support herself and her three daughters.

A little over a year ago, the Social Security Administration requested copies of previous tax returns, which she didn’t have because she doesn’t pay federal income tax, as a result of her disability and other factors, WATE 6 reports. (By not filing taxes, Marban was without one of the common ways people detect identity theft in the first place.) In the correspondence requesting the paperwork, the Social Security office said tax returns had been filed under her Social Security number. Marban said she then reported the identity theft to the police and had a series of hearings regarding her Social Security benefits.

By Dec. 16, 2015, she received a decision on the Social Security: Marban would no longer receive benefits because the tax returns showed she had been employed for the last four years, WATE 6 reports. Several days earlier, Marban had received a letter from the IRS confirming she was a victim of identity theft. It seems that information didn’t make its way to the Social Security Administration.

“If I don’t get a check next month, we will not be here. I use that to pay the rent, utilities, groceries,” Marban told WATE 6.

Marban has a hearing with the Social Security Administration scheduled Jan. 26 to possibly reopen the case.

Marban’s debacle is just one of many examples showing how damaging identity theft can be. Unfortunately, it’s extremely difficult to prevent identity theft, and it’s a common crime. Here are some tips for spotting signs of identity theft, like regularly checking your credit scores for suspicious activity (you can get two free credit scores each month on You should also consider filing your taxes as soon as possible, to head off thieves and more quickly find out if someone has used your Social Security number to file a fraudulent report.

More on Identity Theft:

Image: iStock

You Might Also Like

Find out what someone can do with your stolen Social Security num... Read More

October 19, 2023

Identity Theft and Scams

how to prevent identity theft
The Federal Trade Commission’s Consumer Sentinel Network re... Read More

May 17, 2022

Identity Theft and Scams

A man and woman chat in an office
COVID-19 vaccines are being rolled out across the country, and th... Read More

May 20, 2021

Identity Theft and Scams